Wednesday, June 10, 2009

About the Authors


Figrin (Dustin)

I'm a college student currently double-majoring in Philosophy and Comparative Religion. I think that to a large extent, the topics and people that I study will inform some of the arguments that I present here, but not always in a direct way. I don't plan on citing the work of ancient philosophers or looking to them to form a basis for my ideas, though the ones I've studied will most likely have a part in influencing how I construct my ideas. On the other hand there are modern-day thinkers who have discussed very pertinent issues such as religion and the environment, and I can say that I will probably weigh their ideas when fleshing out my own beliefs.

I was born into a Democratic household, and while I definitely wouldn't align myself with any particular party, I think
it's safe to say that I have a slightly liberal disposition on a lot of issues. I think that everyone's opinions are, to some extent, naturally biased towards the opinions of those around them. I embrace the fact that this certainly applies to myself, but at the same time I have never allowed my opinions to be completely informed by such a bias, as no one should. I want to give the sides to every issue equal consideration, and this is, I think, part of the reason I've decided to participate in this blog.

If I have any stance towards religious issues, it is one of open-mindedness. I don't label myself as an atheist an agnostic or a follower of any particular religion. I am a student of Comparative Religion and a member of my University's interfaith organization, and thus I consider myself at least slightly knowledgeable and respectful of religious ideas. I think that truth can be found in any way of thinking which incorporates the idea of God, and refuse to box myself into any particular camp for fear of developing the close-mindedness that is far too common among those who do.

Ghidrah (Stefan)

I’m a young adult who’s trying to find his path in life. I have regular job and a fairly regular life. I’m not really sure what I’m doing about college, or for that matter, what I’m doing about my future in general, and I think that fact and the fact that I’m still growing and trying to find out who I am will influence my opinions on this blog. That is not to say that my positions will be forever changing, but simply that they will always be developing into something more (and probably a little different) than they were yesterday. I will discover more facts and see things from different points of view as the discussion progresses, but I will generally do this to try and pad my initial position. I’ll tend to fall back on statistics rather frequently; however, there will be times when I’ll argue that statistics mean nothing to the individual.

I am definitely, by Seattle standards, a conservative. I believe that the individual is the most important thing that someone can worry about, on any sort of spiritual or political level. I believe that, in turn, a society is made up of a collection of individuals, and therefore what’s best for the individual is usually what’s best for civilization as a whole. I am very object to the alternative. I will always bite my thumb at societal changes that attempt to benefit everyone at the expense of the individual. But again these views are subject to alteration. I’m willing bend to a certain degree on most topics.

I do not believe in a higher power of any sort. I think that humans are animals that are simply, by our standards, highly advanced. In my opinion, evolution shaped us into what we are today because our current form is the most energy efficient and productive structure possible. We are simply extremely successful organisms who continue to evolve and improve over time. This is not to say that I look at things from a subjective scientific perspective, however. I absolutely think that most scientists are vainglorious snobs who view everything as logical and academic and shun anything that questions their narrow view of the world. There are, quite frankly, many in the world that we will never be able to explain. Some things are just beyond our comprehension, and I like it that way.

Read more...

About the Dialectic

The void of this post is, I think, the only thing in the way of actually jumpstarting real content. So I'm going to start filling that void by just doing some free-associating on what I think the purpose of the blog should be, and how I believe the debate and reader interaction will work. Once Ghidrah has reviewed what I've written, done the same, and we've organized it all into a fancy package of writing, the proverbial ball will officially be rolling.


Many things of a wise and exceptional nature have their roots planted in the thoughts of the ancient Greeks. The word "dialectic" (derived from the Greek dialektikē) is certainly one of these things. Therefore, one arrives at the conclusion that a discussion-based blog which takes this word as its title is also a vessell for things wise and exceptional. At least that's how we've intended it.

In actuality, the word dialectic has been used to denote many different things, including different philosophical concepts and forms of argumentation. It may not be likely that all of these things actually promote wisdom or exceptional thinking. It is almost certain, however, that the idea which lies at the core of what "dialectic" really is, undoubtedly serves as one of the greatest keys to cultivating these two things.

The idea itself is simple: In a constantly shifting world such as ours, there are many opposing forces which we sometimes called opposites (see how that works?). At the same time, we can make connections and see relationships between these opposing forces. Fire and ice are nearly as opposed as things get, but we can still see that this opposition arises from a common relationship to extreme temperatures. Having the ability to identify this relationship allows us to truly appreciate the nature of these opposing forces--to understand what makes them what they are, to perceive the ways in which they interact, and comprehend their place in the infinite spectrum of things hot and cold.

The physical world of opposites, the world in which fire and ice interact, is not the only world in where the concept of dialectic can apply. It also applies to the world of ideas, wherein concepts, thoughts, and most importantly, opinions, interact.

To be continued...
  • Mission Statement (Purpose of the Blog)
  • Mode of Discussion (How the debate will work, how readers interact)
  • Encourage readers to participate

Read more...

Tuesday, June 9, 2009

A To-Do List

I think I've found a decent format for the blog.


We can check that off of the list of things that need to be taken care of before officially launching into some hard-hitting and brain-annihilating discussion.

Other things that I think we need are:
  • An introductory post
  • A subtitle to replace the space under the title where it says "...needs an introduction."
  • Replacement of the image behind the header which just says "Blog" with logo.
  • A list of potential topics for discussion. So far I think have "death penalty, good and evil, vegetarianism" written somewhere. Torture might also be an interesting and pertinent thing to discuss. EDIT: The environmental issue might be a good one as well.
Look at that. A fancy bullet list.

P.S. As we actually begin posting, we will be using the "Labels for this post" space to keep track of our progression on different topics. For instance, if we were to debate the existence of buckets, we might label our relevant posts with "buckets". Try to limit each post to only 1 or 2 important labels so that the "Subjects" column on the right doesn't get clogged with random words that were simply free-associated about the posts made.

Read more...
<<